Imagine you’ve just spent three hours navigating the air-conditioned corridors of the Valley Plaza Mall in Bakersfield. The Central Valley sun is beating down on the asphalt at a relentless 102 degrees. You’re pushing a cart overflowing with bags from Macy’s, a new espresso machine from Williams-Sonoma, and—because you’re a parent—a bulky jogging stroller that seemed like a good idea this morning. Now comes the moment of truth. You click the "trunk" icon on your Tesla app.
Will it all fit?
At Frontier Tesla, we hear this question every single day. Whether you’re a local looking for a weekend "test drive" or a traveler landing at Meadows Field, choosing between the Tesla Model 3 and the Model Y often comes down to one thing: the cargo. While both vehicles are masterpieces of engineering, their storage philosophies are worlds apart.
Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y Trunk Space: The Raw Numbers
To understand which car wins the Bakersfield shopping battle, we have to look at the data. But here’s the thing: cubic footage numbers can be incredibly misleading.
The Tesla Model 3 offers approximately 19.8 cubic feet of total cargo space. This includes the rear trunk, the sub-trunk (the hidden well beneath the floor), and the "frunk" (front trunk). Conversely, the Tesla Model Y boasts a massive 30.2 cubic feet of space behind the second row. If you fold those seats down, that number jumps to a cavernous 72.1 cubic feet.
According to a 2024 independent cargo volume analysis by MotorTrend, the Model Y provides nearly 50% more usable space in its standard configuration than the Model 3. But does that mean the Model 3 is "small"? Not necessarily. It just means you have to be more strategic with your Tetris skills.
Understanding the Model 3’s "Deep" Storage
The Model 3 is a sedan. This is the most important distinction to keep in mind. Because it has a traditional trunk lid rather than a liftgate, the opening is narrower. However, what it lacks in aperture, it makes up for in depth.
I’ve found that many renters are shocked by the "hidden" space in a Model 3. When you lift the carpeted floor panel in the rear, there is a secondary well that is deep enough to hold two full-sized grocery bags or a small carry-on suitcase. This is perfect for keeping fragile items—like those Kern County farmer's market peaches—from rolling around while you’re merging onto the 99.
The Stroller Test: Can You Fit a Stroller and Bags in a Model 3?
This is a deal-breaker for many families. Can you fit a stroller and several bags in a Model 3 trunk?
The answer is yes, but with a caveat. We’ve tested this with standard "umbrella" strollers and mid-sized collapsible strollers like the UPPAbaby Cruz. A standard stroller will fit horizontally across the back of the Model 3 trunk. This leaves enough room for about three to four medium-sized shopping bags on top and in the corners.
However, if you have a double stroller or a large-wheeled jogging stroller (like a BOB), you’re going to struggle. The height of the trunk opening is the limiting factor here. You’ll likely need to remove the stroller’s wheels to get the lid to close. If your Bakersfield shopping trip involves a trip to Target for a bulk pack of diapers and a new car seat, the Model 3 will feel tight very quickly.
Why the Model Y’s Verticality Changes the Game
If the Model 3 is a deep well, the Model Y is a wide-open cavern. Because the Model Y is a crossover SUV, it features a rear hatch (or liftgate) that opens the entire back of the car.
This verticality is the "secret sauce" for heavy shoppers. In the Model Y, you aren't just sliding things in; you’re stacking them up. The roofline is significantly higher, allowing you to stand taller items upright—something that is physically impossible in the Model 3.
Is the Model Y Hatch Better for Loading Groceries?
Absolutely. There is no contest here. When you’re at the Costco on Rosedale Highway, the Model Y hatch is your best friend.
Here’s why:
- The Aperture: The opening of the Model Y is nearly twice as large as the Model 3. You don't have to "angle" large boxes in. You just drop them.
- The Loading Height: The floor of the Model Y is higher, meaning you don't have to lean as far into the car to place heavy items. Your lower back will thank you after a 20-bag grocery run.
- The Power Liftgate: While both cars have power trunks, the Model Y’s hatch provides a bit of a "rain shield" (or sun shield in Bakersfield) while you’re loading.
The "Frunk" Factor: Don't Forget the Front
One of the coolest parts of renting a Tesla from Frontier is the front trunk, or "frunk." Since there’s no internal combustion engine, the space under the hood is yours to use.
Both the Model 3 and Model Y have frunks that are roughly the same size (about 3 cubic feet). What we’ve learned is that the frunk is the perfect place for "smelly" or "messy" items. Did you buy a rotisserie chicken that might leak juice? Put it in the frunk. Did you pick up some pungent takeout from a local Thai spot? Frunk it. This keeps the main cabin smelling fresh and prevents spills on the premium vegan leather seats.
Real-World Scenario: The Costco Run
Let's get practical. We sent two of our team members on a "Bakersfield Shopping Challenge." One took a Model 3, the other took a Model Y.
The goal: A standard Costco run consisting of:
- 1 pack of 40 water bottles
- 2 bags of dog food
- 1 box of laundry detergent
- 4 boxes of assorted groceries
- 1 giant pack of paper towels
The Model 3 Result: Everything fit, but the paper towels had to go in the back seat. The water bottles and dog food took up the entire floor of the trunk, and the grocery boxes had to be stacked precariously. It was a tight squeeze, and visibility through the rearview mirror was slightly obscured.
The Model Y Result: Everything fit in the trunk with room to spare. The paper towels sat comfortably on top of the dog food, and there was still enough space in the sub-trunk to hide a surprise birthday gift. The back seat remained completely empty.
Which Tesla Has More Trunk Space for a Shopping Trip?
If we are talking about pure volume and ease of use, the Tesla Model Y is the clear winner for shopping trips.
However, the Model 3 shouldn't be dismissed. If you are a solo shopper or a couple hitting up the boutiques downtown, the Model 3 is more than sufficient. It’s also slightly more "zippy" and easier to park in those tight mall spaces. But for the "Bakersfield Bulk Buy," the Model Y is the undisputed heavyweight champion.
Key Takeaways: Model 3 vs. Model Y for Local Errands
Before you book your rental with Frontier Tesla, consider these quick points:
- Model 3 is for "Length": If you’re buying something long and thin (like a floor lamp or a rug), the Model 3 with the seats folded down is surprisingly capable.
- Model Y is for "Height": If you’re buying a potted plant from a nursery or a tall kitchen appliance, the Model Y is mandatory.
- The Sub-Trunk is King: Both cars have a "basement." Use it for your valuables to keep them out of sight from passersby.
- Frunk for Food: Use the front trunk for anything that might spill or smell.
Comparison Table: Cargo at a Glance
| Feature | Tesla Model 3 | Tesla Model Y |
|---|---|---|
| Total Cargo Volume | ~23 cu ft | ~76 cu ft (seats down) |
| Opening Style | Traditional Trunk | Power Liftgate (Hatch) |
| Stroller Compatibility | Moderate (Umbrella/Mid-size) | Excellent (All sizes) |
| Grocery Loading | Good (Deep storage) | Superior (Easy access) |
| Frunk Size | ~3.1 cu ft | ~4.1 cu ft |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Which Tesla has more trunk space for a shopping trip, the Model 3 or Model Y?
The Model Y has significantly more space. With over 30 cubic feet of rear storage compared to the Model 3’s ~15 cubic feet (excluding sub-trunk/frunk), the Model Y is designed for high-volume hauling.
Can I fit a stroller and several bags in a Model 3 trunk?
Yes. A standard collapsible stroller will fit, leaving room for 3-5 medium shopping bags. However, you may need to stack bags on top of the stroller, and very large jogging strollers may require wheel removal.
Is the Model Y hatch better than the Model 3 trunk for loading groceries?
Yes, the Model Y hatch is objectively better. The wider opening and higher floor make it much easier to slide in heavy crates, bulk items, and multiple bags without the "lifting and angling" required by the Model 3's sedan trunk.
Does the Model Y have a sub-trunk?
Yes! In fact, the Model Y has two sub-trunk compartments—a large main one and a smaller one closer to the bumper. This provides even more organization for your Bakersfield shopping haul.
Final Verdict: Which Should You Rent?
Here’s my professional advice: If your day in Bakersfield involves more than three stops or any "big box" stores, rent the Model Y. The peace of mind that comes with knowing "it will definitely fit" is worth the small premium in rental price. You’ll spend less time worrying about cargo Tetris and more time enjoying the Full Self-Driving capabilities as you cruise down Truxtun Avenue.
That said, if you’re just in town for a business meeting and a quick stop for a new suit, the Model 3 is a sleek, sophisticated choice that handles a few bags with ease. It’s the "sports car" of the two, and for many, that driving dynamic outweighs the need for extra cubic inches.
Ready to experience the future of driving for your next Bakersfield errand? Book your Tesla Model 3 or Model Y with Frontier Tesla today and pick it up right in the heart of downtown. Your shopping bags are waiting.
Sources
- Tesla Official Model 3 Specifications - Technical data on cargo dimensions.
- Tesla Official Model Y Specifications - Technical data on liftgate and volume.
- MotorTrend 2024 EV Cargo Comparison - Real-world testing of EV storage capacities.
- Car and Driver: Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y Review - Expert analysis of utility and interior space.